Welcome Back!

You still have items in your cart
View Cart
No Thanks

Personalized Valentine's Day Keepsakes

Item offers personalized preview P

Our Valentine's Day keepsakes come with that personalized touch that will really make this year's gift unique and special. From photo puzzles to his and hers mugs to personalized dog tags, we have some creative ideas of gifts to give your significant other that will really say "I Love You" in an unconventional way. You can customize each keepsake for your significant other, 

Testimonial

Looks great, exactly what I wanted.

Molly M Z. - trevose, PA

Valentines Day Keepsakes

47 Products found
Sort By:
Personalized Ceramic Couples Photo Ornament | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$14.98
Couples Photo Glass Ornament
(39)P
Personalized Postcard Keepsake | Personalized Valentines Day Gifts For Her
$26.98
Personalized Postcard Keepsake
(10)P
Engraved Couples Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine Gifts
$34.98
Couples Love Word-Art Heart
(7)P
NEW
Personalized All My Heart and Soul Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts For Her
$36.98
Personalized All My Heart and Soul Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
NEW
Personalized Mr and Mrs Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Wedding Gifts
$36.98
Personalized Mr and Mrs Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
Personalized Love Ornament | Personalized Couples Ornament
$14.98
Personalized Love Ornament
P
Engraved Soul Mates Heart Clock | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$41.98
Engraved Soul Mates Heart Clock
(7)P
Personalized You Are The Missing Piece Heart Puzzle | Personalized Valentine's Gifts For Her
$17.98
Personalized You Are The Missing Piece Heart Puzzle
(2)P
NEW
Personalized Love You Always Photo Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Gifts For Him
$26.98
Personalized Love You Always Photo Acrylic Keepsake
P
Engraved Love Established Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Gifts For Couples
$26.98
Engraved Love Established Acrylic Keepsake
P
NEW
Personalized You Are My Sunshine Photo Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Valentines Gifts For Her
$26.98
Personalized You Are My Sunshine Photo Acrylic Keepsake
P
Endless Love... Message In A Bottle | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$16.98
Endless Love Personalized Message in a Bottle
(33)P
Engraved Dear Valentine Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Valentines Engraved Glass Gifts
$34.98
Engraved Dear Valentine Acrylic Heart Keepsake
NEW
Personalized Photo Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts
$36.98
Personalized Photo Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
Engraved We Love You Acrylic Block Keepsake | Personalized Keepsakes
$30.98
Engraved We Love You Acrylic Block Keepsake
(10)P
Personalized Endless Love Message in a Bottle | Valentine's Day Personalized Gifts For Her
$16.98
Personalized Endless Love Message in a Bottle
(1)
NEW
Personalized Loving Couple Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Gifts For Her
$38.98
Personalized Loving Couple Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
I Believe Valentine Keepsake | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$31.98
Engraved Valentine Keepsake
(2)P
Picture Perfect Love Photo Stone Keepsake U387667
$29.98
Picture Perfect Love Photo Stone Keepsake
(1)P
Personalized Photo Message In A Bottle | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$16.98
Personalized Photo Message In A Bottle
(1)P
NEW
Personalized Always and Forever Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts For Him
$26.98
Personalized Always and Forever Acrylic Keepsake
P
Personalized We Decided on Forever Acrylic Block | Wedding Photo Gift
$26.98
Personalized We Decided on Forever Acrylic Block
P
Engraved Anniversary Keepsake Clock | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$41.98
Engraved Anniversary Keepsake Clock
P
NEW
Personalized Infinity Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts
$26.98
Personalized Infinity Acrylic Keepsake
P
NEW
Embroidered Cupid Hearts Wicker Basket | Romantic Home
$31.96
Embroidered Cupid Hearts Wicker Basket
P
Personalized Mr and Mrs Photo Keepsake | Personalized Couple Gifts
$26.98
Personalized Mr and Mrs Photo Keepsake
P
NEW
Personalized Couples Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Keepsakes
$38.98
Personalized Couples Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
NEW
Personalized All Of Me Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts For Her
$36.98
Personalized All Of Me Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
NEW
Personalized Our Love Grows Beveled Acrylic Keepsake 7123373
$26.98
Personalized Our Love Grows Beveled Acrylic Keepsake
Forever It Will Stay Keepsake Block | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$31.98
Couples Romantic Keepsake Block
P
NEW
Personalized All Of Me Loves All Of You Photo Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Gifts For Her
$26.98
Personalized All Of Me Loves All Of You Photo Acrylic Keepsake
P
True Love Valentine Keepsake
$26.98
True Love Valentine Keepsake
P

Our Valentine's Day keepsakes come with that personalized touch that will really make this year's gift unique and special. From photo puzzles to his and hers mugs to personalized dog tags, we have some creative ideas of gifts to give your significant other that will really say "I Love You" in an unconventional way. You can customize each keepsake for your significant other,