Save 20% Sitewide, No Minimum With Code: ELF2MP


Welcome Back!

You still have items in your cart
View Cart
No Thanks

Personalized Christian Keepsakes

Item offers personalized preview P
Personalized Christian Keepsakes
GiftsForYouNow.com offers a lovely selection of Personalized Christian Keepsakes certain to make any religious event the perfect time to give a thoughtful Christian Keepsake gift. We have Personalized Keepsakes for babies celebrating their christening. We have Personalized Christian Keepsakes to honor your family member making their First Communion or Confirmation.
45 Products found
God's Way of Proving... Personalized Keepsake | Personalized Sister-In-Law Gifts
$26.99
God's Way of Proving... Personalized Keepsake
(22)P
.
Engraved First Holy Communion Oval Glass Ornament 852904
$16.99$14.4415% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Engraved Cross Glass Holiday Ornament
(2)P
.
Engraved Serenity Prayer Keepsake 720682R
$23.99
Engraved Serenity Prayer Keepsake
(1)P
.
Personalized Christian Wall Art | Word-Art Religious Family Wall Canvas
$54.99$23.9956% off!
Sale Ends on 12/31
Personalized Religious Word-Art Canvas
P
.
Confirmation Rosewood Pen Set
$24.49
Religious Rosewood Pen Set
(3)P
.
Personalized Serenity Prayer Garden Flag |Personalized Housewarming Gifts
$17.99$15.2915% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Personalized Serenity Prayer Garden Flag
(2)P
.
Religious Flag |Spring Garden Flags
$17.99$15.2915% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Religious Word-Art Personalized Garden Flag
(11)P
.
Engraved Godmother Glass Mug G210810
$16.99$13.5920% off!
Sale Ends on 12/8
Engraved Godmother Glass Mug
(4)P
.
Glass Picture Frame With Name | Engraved Frames For First Communion
$34.99
Engraved First Holy Communion Cup Glass Frame
P
.
Godmother Keepsake
$26.99$22.9415% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Godmother Keepsake
(2)P
.
Bless Our Home Glass Cross Ornament | Personalized Ornament
$16.99$10.5038% off!
Sale Ends on 12/31
Engraved Bless Our Home Glass Cross Holiday Ornament
(2)P
.
Engraved Christened Wall Cross | Personalized Christening Gifts
$14.99
Engraved Christened Wall Cross
(4)P
.
Serenity Prayer Wall Sign | Personalized Religious Wall Art
$21.99
Personalized Serenity Prayer Wall Sign
(1)P
.
Embroidered God Bless Baby Girl Afghan | Personalized Baby Blankets
$49.99$42.4915% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Embroidered God Bless Baby Girl Afghan
(2)P
.
Godmother Star Keepsake 334107
$28.99$24.6415% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Godmother Star Keepsake
(1)P
.
Confirmation Personalized Keepsake
$31.99
Personalized Confirmation Keepsake
(5)P
.
Godfather Personalized Valet Box | Personalized Godparent Gifts
$31.99
Godfather Personalized Valet Box
(7)P
.
Confirmation Sponsor Keepsake
$26.99
Confirmation Sponsor Keepsake
(3)P
.
Embroidered God Bless Baby Boy Afghan | Personalized Baby Blankets
$49.99$42.4915% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Embroidered God Bless Baby Boy Afghan
(2)P
.
Godchild Personalized Keepsake | Personalized Baptism Gifts
$26.99
Godchild Personalized Keepsake
(3)P
.
Personalized Godparent Picture Frame - Count My Blessings | Personalized Picture Frames
$27.49$10.9960% off!
Sale Ends on 12/31
Personalized Godparent Picture Frame - Count My Blessings
(1)P
.
Personalized Jewelry Box | First Communion Gifts For Girls
$36.99
Personalized Floral Cross Communion Jewelry Box
.
Engraved My First Communion Glass Suncatcher 865354
$16.99$14.4415% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Engraved My First Communion Glass Suncatcher
P
.
Personalized Bless Our Home Garden Flag |Personalized Garden Flags
$17.99$15.2915% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Personalized Bless Our Home Garden Flag
(8)P
.
Personalized Wooden Keepsake Box | Wooden Photo Frame Box
$31.99
Engraved First Communion Keepsake Box
P
.
Word-Art Cross Wall Sign | Personalized Religious Decor
$21.99
Religious Word-Art Personalized Wall Sign
(9)P
.
Engraved Dove First Communion Box | Personalized Keepsake Box
$31.99
Engraved Dove First Communion Photo Box
(2)P
.
Personalized Any Name Cross with Ribbon | Personalized Christian Gifts
$22.49$19.1215% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Personalized Any Name Cross with Ribbon
(2)P
.
Personalized Wooden Keepsake Box | First Communion Gifts
$31.99
Engraved First Communion Cross Keepsake Box
P
.
Glass Communion Frames | Engraved Frames For First Communion
$34.99
Personalized First Holy Communion Glass Frame
P
.
Engraved Blessed First Communion Suncatcher 8111774R
$16.99$14.4415% off!
Sale Ends on 2/28
Engraved Blessed First Communion Suncatcher
P
.
Engraved First Communion Wood Valet Box | Personalized Keepsake Box
$31.99
Engraved First Communion Wood Valet Box
(2)P
.
Personalized Christian Keepsakes
GiftsForYouNow.com offers a lovely selection of Personalized Christian Keepsakes certain to make any religious event the perfect time to give a thoughtful Christian Keepsake gift. We have Personalized Keepsakes for babies celebrating their christening. We have Personalized Christian Keepsakes to honor your family member making their First Communion or Confirmation.

Personalized Christian Keepsakes are perfect for any religious gift giving occasion such as: First Communions, Confirmations and Baptism. We have Personalized First Rosaries & Rosary Cases, Personalized Confirmation Frames, Personalized God Parent coffee mugs and Engraved Godparent Keepsakes. Personalized Christian Keepsakes make great personalized gifts for family and friends.


Get your Personalized Christian Gifts at GiftsForYouNow.com and receive FREE personalization.


Customer Reviews
I purchased this shirt for my daughter. I think these shirts are so cute. The shirts are true to size, which is very important. After I watched them, they didn’t shrink, another important factor, and the material is soft to the touch. My daughter absolutely loved this shirt. I don’t want to forget about mentioning the price...very reasonable for the quality of shirt. Everyone will love these...treat yourself or someone you love.
Shirley A F. - Winter Springs, FL - September, 2019