Welcome Back!

You still have items in your cart
View Cart
No Thanks

Personalized Valentine's Day Keepsakes

Item offers personalized preview P

Our Valentine's Day keepsakes come with that personalized touch that will really make this year's gift unique and special. From photo puzzles to his and hers mugs to personalized dog tags, we have some creative ideas of gifts to give your significant other that will really say "I Love You" in an unconventional way. You can customize each keepsake for your significant other, 

Testimonial

Really nice frame. Loved the way it came out. High quality for not so high price. Very satisfied.

Valerie H. - Woodstock, NY

Valentines Day Keepsakes

59 Products found
Sort By:
Glass Photo Ornament | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$14.98
Glass Photo Ornament
(46)P
NEW
Personalized I Heart Teddy Bear 8314101BX
$27.98
Personalized I Heart Teddy Bear
P
Engraved Couples Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine Gifts
$31.98
Couples Love Word-Art Heart
(9)P
NEW
Personalized Love You To The Moon And Back Wall Decor 91141394X
$59.98
Personalized Love You To The Moon And Back Wall Decor
P
NEW
Personalized Heart Word Art Puzzle with Tin 6140833
$41.98
Personalized Heart Word Art Puzzle with Tin
P
Couples Heart Glass Ornament | Personalized Glass Heart Ornament | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$14.98
Couples Heart Glass Christmas Ornament
(10)P
Personalized Endless Love Message in a Bottle | Valentine's Day Personalized Gifts For Her
$16.98
Personalized Endless Love Message in a Bottle
(3)
NEW
Personalized Sending Lots Of Love And Sweet Treats Jar 2141384
$18.98
Personalized Sending Lots Of Love And Sweet Treats Jar
P
Personalized Postcard Keepsake | Personalized Valentines Day Gifts For Her
$24.98
Personalized Postcard Keepsake
(10)P
NEW
Personalized Our Love Is Sweet Treat Jar 2141094
$18.98
Personalized Our Love Is Sweet Treat Jar
P
NEW
Personalized Heart And Arrow Teddy Bear 8314100X
$27.98
Personalized Heart And Arrow Teddy Bear
P
Personalized Love Ornament | Personalized Couples Ornament
$14.98
Personalized Love Christmas Ornament
P
To My Love Personalized Keepsake Block | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts
$29.98
Personalized Romantic Acrylic Keepsake Block
(7)P
Personalized Couples Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Keepsakes
$33.98
Personalized Couples Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake
(1)P
NEW
Engraved Picture Frames | Couple's Gifts
$27.98
I Love You More Than All The Stars Engraved Frame
P
Couples Word-Art Frosted Mason Jar | Personalized Romantic Gifts
$17.98
Couples Word-Art Frosted Mason Jar
P
Personalized All Of Me Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts For Her
$31.98
Personalized All Of Me Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
NEW
Personalized Valentine's Gift | Photo Keepsakes
$24.98
You Make My Heart Smile Vertical Acrylic Photo Keepsake
P
I Believe Valentine Keepsake | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$29.98
Engraved Valentine Keepsake
(2)P
To My Love Personalized Valet Box | Personalized Romantic Gifts
$26.98
To My Love... Personalized Wooden Valet Box
(8)P
Personalized Loving Couple Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Gifts For Her
$33.98
Personalized Loving Couple Word-Art Acrylic Heart Keepsake
(6)P
Engraved Soul Mates Heart Clock | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$39.98
Engraved Soul Mates Heart Clock
(7)P
Valentine's 2019 Gift Ideas | Valentine's Photo Gifts
$21.98
Personalized Framed Table Top Couples Photo Word-Art Sign
P
Personalized Photo Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts
$31.98
Personalized Photo Acrylic Heart Keepsake
P
Personalized Photo Message In A Bottle | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$16.98
Personalized Photo Message In A Bottle
(2)P
Endless Love... Message In A Bottle | Valentine Keepsake Gifts
$16.98
Endless Love Personalized Message in a Bottle
(35)P
Personalized Love You Always Photo Acrylic Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Gifts For Him
$24.98
Personalized Love You Always Photo Acrylic Keepsake
(1)P
Personalized Coffee Mug | Valentine Mugs
$16.98
You Make My Heart Smile Personalized Coffee Mug
P
Couples Gifts | Valentine's Gift Ideas
$26.98
Personalized Couples Word-Art Block Photo Gift
P
Engraved I Love You Keepsake | Personalized Couple Gifts
$24.98
Engraved I Love You Keepsake
(1)P
Engraved Dear Valentine Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Valentines Engraved Glass Gifts
$31.98
Engraved Dear Valentine Acrylic Heart Keepsake
Personalized All My Heart and Soul Acrylic Heart Keepsake | Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts For Her
$31.98
Personalized All My Heart and Soul Acrylic Heart Keepsake
(1)P

Our Valentine's Day keepsakes come with that personalized touch that will really make this year's gift unique and special. From photo puzzles to his and hers mugs to personalized dog tags, we have some creative ideas of gifts to give your significant other that will really say "I Love You" in an unconventional way. You can customize each keepsake for your significant other,