Save 20% Sitewide, No Minimum With Code: PUMPKIN20


Welcome Back!

You still have items in your cart
View Cart
No Thanks

Easter Basket Stuffers Under $25

Item offers personalized preview P

Easter is Sunday, April 4, 2021!

Easter Baskets Stuffers are a must when filling each basket or egg-hunting tote with lots of goodies! From personalized Easter shirts to adorable stuffed Easter bunnies, we have grouped together a fun collection of gifts under $25 to include in any Easter Basket. For Personalized Easter basket stuffers great for boys, girls and newborn babies celebrating their first Easter, GiftsForYouNow is your shop for all things Easter. 
Testimonial

It's become a tradition that every Father's Day I get a personalized "Dad" shirt for my husband. Giftsforyounow is my go-to! They have always done a beautiful job with the personalization, have quality products, and at an affordable price. Shipping is always very fast or I can pick it up which is my favorite option. He will love this shirt and wear it proudly!

Sarah W. - Woodridge, IL - April, 2019

Easter Basket Stuffers For Toddlers

>
34 Products found
3 Style Options
My First Baby Doll | My First Dolly
$25.99$13.0050% off!
Sale Ends on 10/26
Embroidered Little Darlings Plush Dolly
(69)P
.
Personalized Somebunny Loves Me Easter Bunny | Stuffed Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Personalized Somebunny Loves Me Easter Bunny
(122)P
.
Somebunny Loves Me Personalized Easter Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Somebunny Loves Me Personalized Stuffed Bunny
(879)P
.
Personalized Garden Flag |Easter Flag
$17.99$14.3920% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Easter Bunny Personalized Garden Flag
(5)P
.
Easter Bunny Beanie | White Bunny Knit Hat
$15.99
White Bunny Kid's Knit Hat
(4)
.
Personalized First Easter Brown Easter Bunny | Stuffed Easter Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
First Easter Brown Personalized Easter Bunny
(19)P
.
3 Bunny Color Options!
Custom Easter Bunny | Personalized Easter Bunny
$24.99$11.4954% off!
Sale Ends on 12/31
Stuffed Easter Bunny
(8)P
.
Personalized Easter Baby Bib | Baby Chick Bib
$16.99$13.5920% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Easter Personalized Baby Bib
(1)P
.
Personalized Snuggle Bunny Easter Bunny | Personalized Stuffed Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Personalized Snuggle Bunny Stuffed Easter Bunny
(20)P
.
Personalized Bunny Ears Easter Bunny | Easter Gifts For Baby
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Bunny Ears Personalized Easter Bunny
(8)P
.
Personalized Colorful Easter Eggs with Name Puzzle
$21.99
Personalized Colorful Easter Eggs with Name Puzzle
P
.
Personalized Easter Gift For Kids | Happy Easter Personalized Stickers
$13.99
Bunny Ears Kids Personalized Stickers
P
.
Personalized Easter Egg with Bunny Ears Puzzle
$21.99
Personalized Easter Egg with Bunny Ears Puzzle
P
.
Personalized Easter Bunny |Stuffed Easter Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Personalized Plush Easter Bunny
(63)P
.
Personalized Easter Word Art Puzzle
$23.99
Personalized Easter Word Art Puzzle
P
.
First Easter Personalized Easter Bunny | Easter Gifts For Babies
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
First Easter Personalized Bunny
(9)P
.
Easter Bunny Beanie | Pink Easter Hat
$15.99
Pink Bunny Kid's Knit Hat
(2)
.
Engraved Easter Treat Jar
$37.97
Engraved Bunny Ears Treat Jar
P
.
Easter Gift For Kids | Easter Bunny Necklace with Custom Name
$13.99
Dog Tag Personalized Easter Necklace
(8)P
.
20" Tall!
Stuffed Easter Bunnies | Personalized Easter Bunny
$25.99$17.9931% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Somebunny Loves Me 20-Inch Personalized Bunny
(10)P
.
Personalized Happy Easter Photo Bunny | Easter Photo Gifts
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Photo Personalized Happy Easter Bunny
(5)P
.
Personalized Egg-ceptionaly Cute Easter Bunny | Personalized Stuffed Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Personalized Egg-ceptionaly Cute Easter Bunny
(6)P
.
Personalized First Easter Bunny | Stuffed Easter Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Personalized My First Easter Bunny
(10)P
.
20" Tall!
Personalized Easter Bunnies | Personalized Stuffed Bunny
$25.99$17.9931% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Colorful Easter Eggs 20-Inch Personalized Bunny
(3)P
.
My First Easter Personalized Easter Bunny | Easter Gifts For Babies
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
My First Easter Personalized Easter Bunny
(29)P
.
Somebunny Loves Me Personalized Easter Bunny Stuffed Animal
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Somebunny Loves Me Stuffed Personalized Easter Bunny
(127)P
.
Happy Easter Personalized Easter Bunny | Easter Gifts For Babies
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Happy Easter Personalized Easter Bunny
(4)P
.
20" Tall!
Personalized Bunny Ears Easter Bunny | Easter Gifts For Baby
$23.99$15.9933% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Personalized Bunny Ears 20" Stuffed Easter Bunny
P
.
Personalized Stuffed Easter Bunny | Personalized Easter Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Colorful Easter Eggs Personalized Easter Bunny
(62)P
.
Carrot Love Personalized Easter Bunny | Personalized Easter Bunny
$20.99$12.9938% off!
Sale Ends on 10/31
Carrot Love Personalized Easter Bunny
(2)P
.
Bunny Puzzle for Easter | Personalized Easter Gift For Kids
$21.99
Bunny Ears Kids Personalized Puzzle
(1)P
.
Easter Coloring Book | Personalized Easter Coloring Book
$15.99
Personalized Easter Coloring Book
(3)P
.

Easter is Sunday, April 4, 2021!

Easter Baskets Stuffers are a must when filling each basket or egg-hunting tote with lots of goodies! From personalized Easter shirts to adorable stuffed Easter bunnies, we have grouped together a fun collection of gifts under $25 to include in any Easter Basket. For Personalized Easter basket stuffers great for boys, girls and newborn babies celebrating their first Easter, GiftsForYouNow is your shop for all things Easter. 
Check out our My First Easter onesie and bib set for baby girls and My First Easter bib and Onesie sets for boys! Our personalized Easter gifts make springtime fun! Shop personalized gifts year round to make someone special smile.

Looking for a special Easter gift for your grandchildren?